Let's start with the team needs.
Browns needs: QB, RB, 4OL, 2DL, CB, K
I think its fairly obvious that the Browns are quite weak along both lines. It's not completely their fault as the lines have had more injuries than I thought imagineable, but we do manage to fail to address either line in every draft since we returned to the NFL. I guess that's not entirely true as we spend our third pick on "Lunch Money" Gerard Warren in 2001. We also drafted the underweight vegan center out of Notre Dame who we traded away when we signed LeCharles Bentley. So as usual the Browns poor decisions in the draft have left us in trouble in those positions where the players did not develop into what we had hoped. Looking at the numbers though, the Browns may have been the worst offensive team this side of the Raiders. The fans love Charlie Frye because he is a local blue-collar boy who says all the right things about studying film and effort. The fact of the matter though is that he is barely a serviceable NFL starter. I actually truly believe Frye would make for the perfect backup. So no need to get rid of him and I am certain he would take well to staying in Cleveland as the backup, because he loves the area. Perhaps the biggest problem the Browns offense faces though is the running game. Clearly, the problem begins up front. Our lack of an offensive line hurts the team in every possible way. It gives the QB less time to throw, but more importantly our running backs don't have any holes to gain yards. Look at the Kansas City Chiefs, their offensive line turned Priest Holmes from a backup to the best running back in the league as his peak. I cannot overstate the importance of an offensive line. I think Phil Savage understand this as he signed 2 of the better o-line free agents last year. Unfortunately the Cleveland luck plague kicked in and Bentley got hurt in the first day of training camp sidelining him for last year and potentially even next season. I am going to write this offseason preview under the premise that Bentley won't be playing next season.
Browns significant free agents:
Rakph Brown, CB; Cosey Coleman, OL; Hank Fraley, C; Ethan Kelley, NT; Alvin McKinley, DT; Dennis Northcutt, WR; Brian Russell, S
What is curious about this list is that we could probably afford to let every single one of these players go as none of them are that good. The problem though is that each of these players plays a position where we don't have a guy ready to step in. Who would I re-sign? Ralph Brown was a scrub we signed off the street to fill in when both of Gary Baxter's knees exploded on the same play and McCutcheon went down for the season for the 5th year in a row. Needless to say, the Browns corners are fragile. I would re-sign Brown in a heartbeat, but not with the idea of him starting again. Ideally we can pick up someone in free agency (more on this later), and have Brown as our nickel back. Out of the remaining free agents, I would make a push to re-sign Fraley, Ethan Kelley, and Brian Russell. Fraley will provide insurance in case Bentley is not able to play this year as he was quasi-serviceable on the line last year. Kelley in my mind is great for depth on the line and has shown some flashes. I fully expect Brodney Pool to step up this year and claim a starting safety spot in the secondary next to Super Sean Jones, but Russell has been great at making calls and teaching the youngsters and I again would love to have that depth at safety. It is no surprise to me that the strength of the Browns is our secondary as Romeo began as the secondary coach under the Parcell-Belichik regime with the Giants Super Bowl teams. He may not have figured out head coaching quite yet, but he has coached our secondary into a serviceable unit, which says a lot for this team.
So how do the Browns begin to fill these needs? Last year saw an interesting trend where there were free agents that actually wanted to play for Cleveland and expressed that desire. While this sounds preposterous at first, the underlying theme with these players was that most of them were local boys who actually would like to see this city get a long-awaited championship. Even a punter, Zastudil, wanted to flee the wretched city of Baltimore to come home to his boyhood heroes the Browns. The Browns again see an interesting glut of local Clevelanders that are hitting the free agent market. With cap room to spend we could see an interesting dynamic unfold if we once again sign some of these players. I for one, would love to see the Browns sign one of the top corners on the free agent market and potentially have one of the top 5 secondaries in the league especially given their young age. Who should we bring in then?
Nate Clements, CB, Buffalo Bills
Clements is a local hero who attended the Ohio State University, but even more importantly grew up in yours truly's hometown of Shaker Heights. Clements is probably the second best CB on the market next to Asanta Samuel, who was recently franchise tagged by the Patriots. The Bills recently announced that they will not break the bank to re-sign Clements and I hope that the Browns are willing to spend some of that excessive cap space on bringing Nate home. Pairing the electric Clements with Leigh Bodden could prove to be one of the toughest and most underappreciated corner duos in the league.
Kris Dielman, OL, San Diego Chargers
Much of the hoopla surrounding free agent offensive linemen centers around the Bengals guard, Eric Steinbach. Dielman is another local Ohioan having attended Troy high school and has expressed his desire to come home to play for the Browns. Another interesting dynamic at play is that one of his former coaches, the Chud, is the new Browns offensive coordinator. The Chud has been rumored to have been pushing for bringing in Dielman and I find it likely that he is a solid guard as he has been blocking for Ladainian Tomlinson the past few years. Dielman also happens to be bigger than Steinbach which is something I think that bodes better for the cold weather of Cleveland. He will also be significantly cheaper than Steinbach.
As far as other local boys that may have an interest in playing at home, both Mike Doss and London Fletcher are free agents. While I don't see the Browns making a push to sign either player, Mike Doss has explicitly stated that he wants to play for the Browns next season. Well, I would be willing to sign Doss to a small contract and have him as depth in the secondary, I hope we don't overpay an injury-prone player to bring him home. There are also a few interesting unrestricted free agents at kicker. Both Rian Lindell and Josh Brown are free agents and while I doubt their teams let either player go, we would be wise to swoop in and get one of them if they don't re-sign. The Browns most important need remaining in free agency would be the defensive line.
Terdell Sands, DT, Oakland Raiders
Sands is a young defensive line widebody who has benefited greatly from playing next to Warren Sapp. He would fit in perfectly playing at the DE spot in the 3-4 and could reunite with Ted Washington and learn from another seasoned vet. Sands will likely command a pretty big fee for being relatively unknown as he is one of the better young defensive free agents available. That said, the Browns would be wise to bring him in the replace Alvin McKinley. I know its difficult to sell on bringing in a Raider as they were truly awful last year, but their defense was not too terrible upon further looks. While I would not be crushed if we were not able to sign this player, I think what stands out to me is that he is young and I like this approach to building the team with younger players who will grow together.
The Browns hopefully will be able to bring in a few other cheap players such as Mike Doss, but I see them trying to fill the remainder of their needs in the draft. I will be back with Part 2 later on to discuss who I think the Browns should be taking in the draft and the interesting dilemma that faces them in choosing between the stud RB or one of the top QBs that are available as both positions in my opinion are a big need.